I’ve often been told that I have the face for radio. In fact, during my first stab at college I was briefly employed as a DJ in a Top 40 radio station in a neighboring town. Actually, I was employed for one whole day. I was hired to man the dials for the early morning shift on a Saturday mornings. Unfortunately, the Friday night before my first shift had been a pretty heavy one – a big fraternity party – and I’m pretty sure I was still a bit drunk when I turned up for work. I got through the shift all right but on the way home around midday I rear-ended a car and totaled my truck. Upstate South Carolina is known for a lot of things, but public transportation isn’t one of them. Since I couldn’t find someone who was willing to wake up at 5 a.m. on Saturday mornings to take me to work, my budding radio career ended right there on U.S. Highway 76.
Probably a good thing, as the day of the DJ is long gone and I don’t really have the stomach to be a talk radio host. You see, after a week spent listening to Savage and Levin, I was all prepared to come out today guns a-blazing in my best impression of a talk jock. I was ready to spew vitriol and poorly researched opinions masked as fact. I was poised to skewer the American health care disaster, was itching to tear down the lies that have been spread surrounding tax rates in countries with socialized health care, was formulating a conceit about the mythical ‘Middle Class’ in America.
But then as I was walking to catch the bus this morning I asked myself “What’s the point?”
When I write political rants I basically only get myself upset. For the most part I’m preaching to the choir and if you disagree with me I’m not arrogant enough to believe that you’re going to change your mind. What’s the point? Post another picture of the boy and move on.
I mean, I know that I pay a lower tax rate in Australia (26% versus 28% plus) then I would (and did) in the US. It’s hard to gauge the quality of health care, but I know that the infant mortality rate is lower in Britain (4.8 per 1,000) and Australia (4.4) than it is in the US (6.3). I also know that life expectancy is higher in Britain (77.7) and Australia (79.8) than it is in the US (76.1). I know that, if you’re an American taxpayer, you’re getting screwed – that most of your taxes are going to pay for a ridiculously bloated and largely unnecessary military rather than the basic necessities for your survival. I know that I’ve gotten outstanding, compassionate medical care in all three countries. I know that the only difference is that in Australia and Britain I don’t pay for it and they make house calls.
I know all these things because I’ve experienced all three systems. I know what I prefer and I know that I wouldn’t even consider moving back to my homeland unless they sorted out the health care mess. I would much rather pay taxes that get reinvested in the health care system than pay insurance premiums that just line the pockets of insurance company executives. I can’t imagine going back to the States and relying on the fickle rules of some insurance company or my employment status for my son’s well being.
It’s not just health care – there’s education. In the Western European style social democracies, one of the responsibilities of the government is to offer affordable tertiary education to those who desire and have earned the opportunity. Therefore, university costs are heavily subsidized. In fact, a university education was free until very recently in the UK.The cost of a college education has skyrocketed in the last couple of decades in the U.S., pricing a lot of people out of the market and leaving the rest massively in debt after four years. I know from first-hand experience. It’s important to me that my kids have a shot at a university education, but another reason I would be reluctant to return to the States is that we should have started saving about five years ago in order to pay for it.
Let’s assume, as Dr. O’C prays, that Boy Z becomes a scholar. What would it cost to send him to the finest higher education institution in the three countries under discussion? We’ll focus on public institutions*, assume resident tuition and include all estimated living costs (food, housing, etc. all in U.S. dollars). To get a Bachelor’s degree from Oxford University would cost us about $45,000. The same degree from the Australian National University in Canberra would leave us about $41,000 poorer. But, if Boy Z decided to head to the Sodom of the Left Coast and got his degree from UC Berkeley, we’d be $114,000 in debt. Even if he went to my alma mater, the finest university in the South – The University of Georgia, we’d still be down $68,000.
I’ve gone further with this than I intended – but with less ranting than originally planned at least. And this is where I ask again – what’s the point? If you’re reading this and aren’t living in Britain or Australia (or Canada or Sweden or France or Germany or Latvia or basically any other industrialized country) and you’re now convinced that a touch of socialism is a good thing, chances are you’re not packing your bags.
I guess the point is that the people who are telling you that socialized medicine doesn’t work are either liars or idiots. Or both. The people who are teabagging and telling you that higher taxes will break the back of the middle class are either dangerously deceitful or morons. The fact of the matter is that you, those of you who are residents of the US, are getting the shaft.
To be 100% honest, I really don’t think it’s going to change. This idea – that taxes and government are bad – is so ingrained in the American psyche that I don’t believe even the new administration with Democratic majorities in both houses is going to be able to sort it out. I did the same thing that a lot of you did – 52% in fact – voted for Obama and hoped that he would be able to change what is a broken system. I know it’s early, I know he has a year or so to take the big steps that need to be taken before the 2010 congressional races start up.
But listening to these guys on the Right and listening to the people that call in to their shows, I just don’t think it is going to happen.
Well, there’s some upbeat Friday reading for you, gentle readers. Y’all have a good weekend, you hear?
————————–
* Just for kicks, I checked out Harvard – $208, 000.
The Killers’ “Hot Fuss” is a great record and is available from
.
Image credits:
Popularity: 34% [?]

Stumble Upon
Del.icio.us
Buzz















by zayzayem
17 Apr 2009 at 18:09
I’m not on top of the whole HECS -> HELP switch we’ve had here, but isn’t higher education in Australia still no up-front costs with loans only repayable once you start earning*.
It’s the closest to free you can get!
*I’ve just inched over this threshold. My last pay “rise” was net negative $30/month =(
by SSG
17 Apr 2009 at 18:49
Woah, dude, things might change in future, you just don’t know. And you didn’t look at Scotland- cheaper cost of living and only pay graduate endowment- Scotland values Education pretty highly I think. And other countries in Europe also have cheap degrees. Also Oxford, and other places in the UK, are means tested tuition fees. I paid £30 a year for mine. And my living costs were about £4000 a year, so my whole degree cost me about £13,000. But then I also worked every holiday, and also got scholarships here and there to offset some of that- £3,000 from Gatsby, £250 every year from college, £300 for hardship fund and all that… so it is doable much cheaper.
Oh, and you better be having a girl, or a boy who liked pink, cos that’s the way the blanket is going.
SSGs last blog post..Finish the sentence…
by SSG
17 Apr 2009 at 18:59
PS this song rocks
SSGs last blog post..Finish the sentence…
by suzer
17 Apr 2009 at 19:11
I emailed that 1st pic to my aunt, who is a nun. Remind me when we eventually meet face-to-face to tell you the story of the knife.
suzers last blog post..Friends
by headbang8
17 Apr 2009 at 20:41
Arizaphale, Miss Betty and I studied law, and didn’t pay for it. Not one cent. And we got a living allowance. That’s how it was in Oz back then.
The government foot the bill, in the belief that it would encourage gifted children of the working class to go to university, rather than being forced into early employment. Studies showed that after a decade or so of this, the policy made pretty much no difference at all–social mobilty remained static. So they introduced the Higher Education Contribution Scheme, to make sure that those who can afford it, pay for it. It’s structured to be manageable for kids of modest means, but to make sure that the government reclaims the dough from you, when and if your degree starts returning big bucks for you.
You will notice that neither Arizaphale, Miss Betty nor I practice law, in any form. In fact, only one of us graduated. Was this because we had no skin in the game? Did we undervalue the opportunity, because it was free? Perhaps. But it did give us the freedom to jettison a career which we discovered would fill our lives with endless conflict and nastiness, among colleagues who are, for the most part, jerks, petty bastards, and social retards. Hooray for small-s socialism.
headbang8s last blog post..Interview 2009. My Best Straight Male Friend.
by kitty
17 Apr 2009 at 20:46
Well said. University used to be free here. They brought HECS in my fresher year. It was like they were waiting for me to start. As a non-commonwealth supported graduate student, my fees are still a little on the hefty side, but still I’m grateful to live under the system I/we do.
kittys last blog post..the sublime to the ridiculous
by Joe
17 Apr 2009 at 22:18
Are you trying to stage a mass exodus from these here states of the united? I’ve told the wife on a few occasions that we need to pack up, but she won’t move away from her family. I think I’m here for the long haul and will have to just content myself with looking over the fence into your yard.
Joes last blog post..I Think the Window was Fogged Up
by The Unbearable Banishment
17 Apr 2009 at 22:31
Ugh. Thanks for nothing. Read this over breakfast and it spoiled a perfectly good bowl of corn flakes.
The Unbearable Banishments last blog post..random nyc pic
by Jacob
17 Apr 2009 at 23:13
Damn. I should have gone to Oxford. That’s cheap. Isn’t Oxford like THE University in the English-speaking world?
Jacobs last blog post..I Would Be the NPR Outcast
by Angel
17 Apr 2009 at 23:54
I had a huge comment typed, but like you, I feel quite defeated and think what’s the point. I’ve realized I just don’t flipping care anymore. There’s no point. I’m too exhausted. It’s like spitting in the wind.
(And I have no idea why this won’t show my newer posts.)
Angels last blog post.."I would love to coach there someday… " (but I’m not wearing those damn flipflops)
by April
18 Apr 2009 at 00:36
A little note from the Sodom of the Left Coast: and don’t forget that student loans are not subject to bankruptcy protection. Thank you Michael Moore.
The thing is, our family is all here, and in truth, to me that is more important than all the money and stress in the world. That’s why we won’t leave the US long term, that’s why we’re already plotting and scheming ways to move back to the mid-west, despite becoming accustomed to Bay Area living and the great weather. Sometimes I stop and wonder if it would be better for Jocelyn if we moved abroad, give her less stress about college and health care in her future. Somehow still, a life where she gets to spend quality time with her Grandparents, Uncles and Cousins still wins out because I’m a sentimental sap and I really enjoyed those relationships in my childhood. I’m no nationalist, it’s just that home is where the heart is.
And I don’t understand that “I’ve got soul but I’m not a soldier” song, I like The Killers and all, but that song and the “Are we human, or are we dancers” one leave me scratching my head.
Aprils last blog post..Book Review: The Optimist’s Daughter by way of The Book Club Cookbook
by Jamie
18 Apr 2009 at 01:58
I am usually a pessimist, but I have a small glimmer of optimism that some change is possible – thanks in part to mouth-breathing “rodeo clowns” like Glen Beck (his words about himself – I kid you not). By ranting on about socialism all the time, they are actually introducing the concept of socialism into the American political vocabulary. And once people realize small s socialism means affordable health care not beholden to the insurance industry, maybe they will be less scared of it. My arch-conservative parents even think there should be some sort of public health care available to all.
And the anti-tax, anti-government attitude is increasingly over-stated. As someone who has attended all kinds of protests, the teabaggers had a pathetic turnout–even with Fox news pimping the protests for months and millions of dollars in organizing money from Conservative foundations. Plus, I think most Americans realize Obama has not raised their taxes, but cut them unless you are uber-rich.
All said, I am sure I will be ready to emigrate again by next week.
by Carolyn Online
18 Apr 2009 at 04:05
Ok, I swear I read to the end and digested all of the good points about taxes etc. but I got stuck on Hwy 76. I went to Clemson and had my fair share of near misses on 76. Small world.
Carolyn Onlines last blog post..Armageddon, I mean Amsterdam: Part Two.
by courtney
18 Apr 2009 at 04:08
You preach to the choir, my friend. (Mostly. I know you do have some conservative readers.) I think we Americans are all fully aware we’re getting the shaft; the question is how many people are willing to forego the name-calling and narrow-mindedness and let Obama try to do something about it.
Maybe Boy Z will get a full scholarship somewhere and all your worrying will be for nothing.
One more thing: Upstate SC is known for many things? Um, like what?
courtneys last blog post..I Want To Punch Quentin Tarantino In The Mouth
by Southern (in)Sanity
18 Apr 2009 at 06:13
I will agree with you about the spending of tax revenue here in the United States. Unfortunately, it seems that the new administration is set to spend even more – rather than re-allocating and prioritizing the current available funds. Whether or not Obama will cut taxes remains to be seen, but someone at some point in time will have to pay for all of this spending. It may be my nephew’s generation or further down the line, but someone will pay.
I don’t agree with this higher spending, and I certainly don’t agree with higher taxes until some type of action is taken for some accountability with spending. If that makes me “dangerously deceitful” or a “moron,” so be it.
I wish I could believe that socialized medical care was this great, but I have talked to people who have lived in Canada and the UK. One person’s father, in his 70’s, was denied heart surgery. Why? They didn’t come right out and say it, but the family was given the impression that, “Hey, he’s old … and he’ll die anyway.” Another person had to wait more than a year for a surgical procedure.
The scariest thing is how much the current federal government in the United States has gone beyond the structure that was initially created by the U.S. Constitution. As one local radio host said on Wednesday at a local tea party, kids in an eighth grade civics class are taught things about the Constitution that should show them – let alone adults – that the government has gone far beyond its responsibility and “rights” for many years – under both Democratic and Republican leadership.
by admin
18 Apr 2009 at 10:42
Z – I don’t know about the past of Australian higher ed, I used ANU’s current estimates of costs for a resident student.
SSG – Again, just focusing on average costs at one university in each country. Sure, things can change. I just don’t think they will.
Suzer – Look forward to hearing it.
Headbang8 – That’s what I was trying, ineloquently, to get across. Small s socialism offers more of a chance to succeed than small c capitalist systems. Thanks.
Kitty – Grad school is different. I got paid to go to grad school in the States. Funded by the federal government, I might add.
Joe – Not at all. I just think if anything is ever going to change in the States people really need to understand what goes on in ’socialist’ countries.
TUB – You’re welcome.
Jacob – Yeah, but you would have had to have UK citizenship first!
Angel – Fair enough.
April – I know what you’re saying, but my decision is based on my children. It would be good to be closer to family, but I think we’ll be able to afford to travel more than we would if we lived in the States.
Jamie – I hope you’re right. Maybe I need to stop listening to Right Wing talkies.
Carolyn – I was at a small private school in Clinton. Used to go to Clemson to party.
Courtney – Uh, racism?
SIS – This is exactly what I’m talking about. No offense, but you hear these kind of apocryphal stories from the right all the time. Someone’s friend’s uncle was refused treatment, someone’s Aunt’s bridge partner had to wait six years to have her appendix out. It’s bull. The only time I’ve heard of treatment being refused by the NHS or Medicare is for experimental treatments and then there is always the option of going private within Oz or the UK. It’s crap, SIS.
If we were refusing treatment to old people, why do Brits and Australians (who have similar lifestyles to Americans) living longer? It’s propaganda spread by people who have never lived in the UK or Aus or disgruntled right wing expats.
If you want accountability in spending, start with the defense department.
And this is what I mean, this is why I didn’t want to write a post like this. Just raises my blood pressure. I should just get on with it, safe in the knowledge that I’m getting the better deal.
by Jill/Twipply Skwood
18 Apr 2009 at 11:35
You must have gotten your internet back – I’m three posts behind now! And also a tad depressed about where I happen to live. But oh well, what can I do? We might lack decent health care and university programs, but at least we’ve got the cockroaches and hurricanes. I guess teabagging is all the rage now, huh?
Jill/Twipply Skwoods last blog post..Because my Car Registration Sticker DESERVES to be Showered in Affection…
by arizaphale
18 Apr 2009 at 12:37
No, you gotta keep ranting AFM because remember, if you save ONE starfish………….
SIS: Public Health Care is not perfect but it is ‘free’. In Aus, you also have the option of seeing another practitioner if you don’t like the advice the first one gives. If all else fails you can go private if you want to get through the system faster. It’s the ability to choose which makes it all worthwhile.
headbang:I never qualified for the living allowance
but I do thank the Govt for two years of fascinating life experience in between tutorials at the Uni Bar. Didn’t you graduate either?
In defence of our flippant attitude to this generous opportunity to undertake higher study ‘on the house’, we were very young and arrogant. By the time I’d grown up and decided what I really wanted to do with my life……….nope it was still free then too. Just lucky I guess. Aussie Aussie Aussie!!!!
Makes me wonder what my taxes are paying for now though as it OBVIOUSLY isn’t the universities. All you hear about is how their funding is being cut.
arizaphales last blog post.."As Our Trekcart Goes Rolling Along"*
by Damon
18 Apr 2009 at 15:01
AFM – Another fine post! I’m learning a great deal about Australia beyond what I’ve seen via television, movies, etc. I suppose an American who has never traveled beyond North America might make the assumption that English-speaking countries have similar ideologies. I had. I definitely won’t anymore.
A couple of points – I noticed Headbang8 say that he may have “undervalued the opportunity (to go to law school), because it was free” He further mentioned that he does not even practice law. Arizaphale’s message was similar – went to the university “on the house” and then after growing up a bit, went back – also free. Someone else is paying the bill. I clearly want my children to EARN and APPRECIATE their education.
Healthcare – I could talk for hours about how broken healthcare is in the U.S., but bottom line – even if you’re an illegal immigrant, a homeless man, a prostitute, or a welfare mom…if YOU come into the ER – you are required to be seen by a physician. Laid off workers who would lose their private insurance have the option of continuance via C.O.B.R.A http://www.dol.gov/dol/topic/health-plans/cobra.htm
Bottom line, I’d like to just agree to disagree. I love this country and would never leave it. I believe in the Founding Fathers and the Constitution. As a moderate conservative, I could care a less if the President is black (he’s actually biracial), I am not afraid of the unknown, & I do not hate women. I am tired of hearing the term “teabagging.”
I do enjoy your posts…I really do.
Damons last blog post..What to do with the 2nd Half of My Life, Part Duh
by admin
18 Apr 2009 at 15:13
Fair enough, Damon. The thing is, I like to hear from people that disagree with me. That’s the reason I’ve been trying to find a new right wing talk show to listen to!
by NATUI
18 Apr 2009 at 15:28
I guess I just need to say Amen. Glad you posted despite your misgivings.
NATUIs last blog post..Nothing Left But Ashes
by yellojkt
19 Apr 2009 at 02:24
Those numbers you have for Hippie U and Uga’s Fire Hydrant are in-state numbers. My son is costing me $35K a year at the North Avenue Trade School, which puts is smack half way to that little school in Cambridge (Mass, not England).
yellojkts last blog post..Gondolamania
by headbang8
19 Apr 2009 at 07:54
Trust me, Damon, I paid for it through taxes! And I was happy to do so.
What both Arizaphale and I did, was put the course credits to good use in degrees we DID value, no less because the tuition was paid.
In both our cases, we went straight to law school from high school (that’s a difference between the US and British systems) so frankly, it was more like a case of changing majors.
One of the things we were able to do because it was free, was to follow our natural bent rather than being forced to complete a law degree in order to make money to pay for it. I regard the system turning out an educated man, as opposed to a skilled lawyer, as a success.
That said, I think both Ariza and I would agree that there were a few who did actually abuse the system, and it’s one of the reasons why the system changed. But the principle that we, as a community, ought to band together to help our young people get the best start in life, and to follow their instincts, is a ood one.
headbang8s last blog post..Photo Friday: Circular
by Damon
19 Apr 2009 at 08:21
Headbang8 – I appreciate you taking the additional time to clarify your situation and that of others who have used the Australian university system. Honestly, I wish the U.S. had more undergrad/grad accelerated programs. I know some universities have a program to combine undergrad/med school with completion in six years. Like so many other aspects of American society, we see so many people abusing the system and giving nothing in return…this is what drives me to drink that extra glass of wine…cheers!
Damons last blog post..What to do with the 2nd Half of My Life, Part Duh
by tysdaddy
19 Apr 2009 at 09:24
I think about this stuff quite a bit. I have a prof from Canada, and he is constantly talking about the differences in the health care system.
Here I am, laid off, and worrying about my kiddos. They have some coverage, and will be alright if things get bad. But I have no insurance at present. And that’s scary. Last time I got laid off, I ended up in the hospital. Even with their assistance, I still ended up paying way more than I could afford.
I’m not smart enough to know the ins and outs, but I’m just bored enough to worry . . .
tysdaddys last blog post..Corona
by mickey
20 Apr 2009 at 06:04
So how exactly do I go about bailing out of this mess and moving down under? Sign me up.
My very first speech in my freshman Public Speaking class (at no less of a fine southern institution than your own) was titled “Taxes are Good.” I was attempting to counter the very anti-tax attitude you speak of. It’s funny that any people who pay such a large percentage of their income into the tax coffers should have such a dim view of the concept; not that they should be happy about it, exactly, but you’d think they would be more aware of what their taxes do for them and more involved in making that money do even more.
Ensuring adequate health care and education for the entire population would be a good place to start.
mickeys last blog post..I’m working on it, I promise
by chris
20 Apr 2009 at 16:45
Thanks Freeman, totally depressed now. My family knows firsthand about the giant suckage of American healthcare. I hear so many people hereyapping about how socialized med doesn’t work but everyone I know who’s experienced it has an overall positive experience. I worked for a comapny that also had a group of employees in Canada and the only complian I ever heard was that there were occasional waits for non-emergency surgeries. Still, my husband and I have hemmed and hawed and gone without care becuase if not wanting to be stuck with more ten thousand+ dollar bills.
All I can say is the system is broken my friend.
chriss last blog post..Easter Phony
by Danielle
20 Apr 2009 at 20:51
“The fact of the matter is that you, those of you who are residents of the US, are getting the shaft.”
Word.
I personally have come to the conclusion that there is conspiracy going that ensures (most) American’s health care and annual leave plans are so ultra-crap that Americans don’t have enough time or energy left when they get their days off to actually roam outside of the country and SEE for themselves that, perhaps, there are some things that other countries are doing a bit better. It’s quite sad. Especially because so many Americans are so indoctrinated to “their way” that when someone talks about possible alternatives they absolutely freak out. (Hello dad: Barack is not a commie.) And about going back to what the Founding Fathers wanted. Get over it. No government can exist in a time vacuum, change is not going to destroy us all.
(Qualifications for my crazy co-rant: lived outside of the U.S. for 5 years total and in 4 countries.)
but, obviously I’m in the choir haha.
Danielles last blog post..Baby Back Ribs
by lora
20 Apr 2009 at 23:30
I have to come back and read this post later this morning, after I’ve had a pot of coffee!
It’s deeper than I can handle right now.
But I wanted to say regarding the plastic bag ban, that’s wonderful!
I hate plastic bags. Before this reusable sack craze here in the states, I exclusively used paper. I also did most of my shopping regularly enough that I only needed my backpack or a large bag to carry my things home. It’s hard to get to the market each day now with a kid, I’m sure I don’t need to explain that to you!
loras last blog post..
by admin
22 Apr 2009 at 12:15
Jill – We did get internet, but it’s not great. Expensive and a really low download limit. Bastards.
Ariza – I don’t know anything about starfish and I’m off my political kick now!
NATUI – Cheers.
Yello – I know, I kept it in state to make things more or less equal. In reality, if Zach were to go to UGA, unless we moved to Georgia, it would cost a small fortune.
Headbang – And all three of you are in jobs that require a university degree.
Damon – That’s one of the reasons for the discrepancy in cost. A Bachelor’s degree in the UK or Oz is three years as opposed to 4. They’re not so interested in a liberal arts education here. I have mixed feelings about that as I think a liberal arts focus makes people more interesting, but it is a bit of a waste of time and money.
Tys – No offense, but your situation is my worst nightmare and the reason I won’t come back.
Mickey – Well, the bad news is that it ain’t easy. The Australian government won’t let just anyone in. In fact if I wasn’t (de facto) married to an Australian citizen, I probably wouldn’t be able to get in. The best chance for you is to be a third world refugee. Hey, give it some time. If the American economy doesn’t shape up maybe you will be.
Chris – Yeah, sorry about that.
Danielle – You may be the first commentator to use ‘word’ in that particular manner. Well done. I know that you’re happily in my situation now. Isn’t it nice to have one less damn thing to worry about?