(Or on Puff the Magic Dragon and masculinity.)

puff3

One of my favourite sources for kids’ music is Cover Lay Down’s Kidfolk series. Not too long ago, one of Boyhowdy’s featured tracks was a version of “Puff the Magic Dragon” by Peter Yarrow of Peter, Paul and Mary fame. “Puff” is a song that I remember fondly from my own childhood, one that my Dad used to sing to me. Hearing it again after a couple of decades, I was struck by how sad a song it is – little boy grows up and leaves his childhood behind. Nonetheless, it has made it into my boys’ bedtime regime. In fact, it has become Boy Z’s “favourite”.

But after a couple of nights, I jettisoned the new version featured on Cover Lay Down for the Peter, Paul and Mary original from the early sixties. Over  two little words in the second verse.

The original…

“Dragons live forever,
But not so little boys…”

Yarrow’s modified version…

“Dragons live forever
But not so little girls and boys…”

puff2It’s Yarrow’s song, so I guess if he wants to bugger up the meter he’s well within his rights.  But the awkward meter, as you probably guessed, isn’t my main problem. No, the problem is that this is a song about a little boy. In my experience, in fact, it’s a song for little boys and their fathers. Why can’t it remain so? That relationship is an important one and, in many cases, an unfortunately uncommon one. In the ongoing quest for gender equality, does everything have to become ‘gender neutral’?

Don’t get me wrong. I’m as much of a feminist as the next guy. Actually more of a feminist than most next guys. Especially in Australia. I believe firmly in gender equality at every level of society. But while I believe that men and women, boys and girls, are equal I do not believe they are the same. Anyone who does is misguided, if not delusional. We’re biologically different, we’re genetically different, we’re psychologically different, we have different life experiences and develop differently as children. That being the case, what’s wrong with having songs for boys and songs for girls? And songs for both? Why do we have to pretend that the experience of growing up as a boy is the same as the experience of growing up as a girl?

Maybe I’m a chauvinist, but for me “Puff” is a boy’s song and when I sing it, I sing the original.

puff1I’ve been thinking a lot about masculinity lately. I had coffee with a new friend last week who’s working on his second book – a memoir about men and their relationships with one another.  And that conversation spurred me to think about my relationships with men, which have traditionally been pretty poor. Most of my good friends in the last twenty years or so have been women. I’ve never been particularly comfortable in the company of men; always felt like I was on the outside looking in. That’s changed in the last few years and these days I’m a lot more at ease around blokes. (The secret? Talk about sports.*) Now I’ve got boy children and I want those boys to be able to move effortlessly into the fraternity of men if that is their wish. It will make adolescence much, much easier.

And those boys, especially the older one, are looking to me as a model of masculinity.  Boy Z idolises me, and it’s a slightly disconcerting feeling for me. I’ve thought of myself as a lot of things in my life, but a role model has never been one of them. For the next several years, I’m likely to be the predominant male role model in my boys lives. I’ve only recently worked out how to be a man. Poor bastards.

And I think “Puff the Magic Dragon” offers one of those lessons. It is OK to have things for boys. It is OK to have things for girls. This doesn’t mean that boys are better than girls or that girls are better than boys. It means that boys and girls are different. Writing that down makes it seem retrograde and reactionary. ‘Different but equal’ sounds a little bit like ’separate but equal’. Maybe I’m setting back gender relations in my own small way. But I think we’d be silly to pretend that raising boys and raising girls is the same process. I know it’s just a kid’s song, a folly, but for me “Puff” will always be a song for little boys.

And I’m glad to have it.

——————————

Peter, Paul and Mary’s original version of “Puff the Magic Dragon” is one of many great tracks on “The Very Best of Peter, Paul and Mary”, available from Peter, Paul And Mary - The Very Best of Peter, Paul and Mary.

Broken Social Scene’s dreamy cover is available on a compilation called “See You On the Moon! – Songs for Kids of All Ages” also available from Broken Social Scene - See You On the Moon! - Songs for Kids of All Ages.

* And ladies.

 
icon for podpress  Peter, Paul and Mary "Puff the Magic Dragon" [3:30m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download

 
icon for podpress  Peter and Bethany Yarrow "Puff the Magic Dragon" [4:01m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download

 
icon for podpress  Broken Social Scene "Puff the Magic Dragon" [5:05m]: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download

Popularity: 9% [?]