I’m becoming a big fan of Adelaide’s Independent senator Nick Xenophon. He’s one of those rare politicians who is thoughtful and deliberate and votes not along party lines but for his convictions. He’s staunchly anti-gambling, an unpopular position in a nation that’s been overrun by ‘pokies’ and multi-million dollar lotteries. I’m with him 100% on that stance, not for any moralistic reasons, but because gambling is, at its very root, a tax on the poor*.
But that’s not what I came to tell you about. Came to talk about China.
Xenophon made the front page of The World’s Worst Newspaper™ last week when he launched a campaign on food security. He’s worried about how much of Australia’s food is imported and that much of it is deceptively labeled as “Made in Australia”. He cited China in particular, pointing out that we already import 7% of our food from the Asian superpower, who also happens to be Australia’s largest merchandise export market. As he told the ‘newspaper‘, “If we become reliant on one country (China) that can be unhealthy. If we don’t keep our primary production up then there is a vulnerability in having to rely on another country for supply, whether there is a supply chain problem or a political dispute”.
I’ve got no real problem with China in general. They’re clearly the up and coming super power, poised to take over from a beleaguered America. And why not? The West has had its shot for the last couple of centuries. We’ve not done a bang up job of it. Maybe we’ll be better off with our Chinese overloads. Sure, they’re not that into human rights but they don’t seem as disposed to spreading their particular political philosophy than were their American and British predecessors. In fact, China just seems perfectly content just spreading cheap computers, shoes and plastic toys.
The latter is what I’m unhappy about. I’m a bit bothered by the fact that so much of what I buy comes from China. It isn’t environmentally sound, there are major issues with safety and if you want a cautionary tale of what happens when you ship all your manufacturing to China, look at the American economy.**
I understand why most manufacturing has shifted to China. I don’t like it, but I understand. I don’t want to pay twice as much for my iPod either. But why food? Australia produces enough food to feed Australia. Hell, we export food – $11.5 billion dollars worth in 2009. Why on earth do we need to import Chinese garlic, onions, beans, potatoes, tomatoes, oranges, cashew nuts, jams and juice. We can grow all of these things in Australia.
It’s a rhetorical question. I know the answer. Because it’s cheaper to grow an orange in China than it is to grow an orange in Australia. Just like it’s cheaper to grow an iPhone in China than it would be in Australia. Without pesky food standards and unions and minimum wages, China can produce anything Australia can at a fraction of the price. And Woolies likes cheap food and higher profit margins.
But you know what? I don’t want Chinese oranges. For environmental reasons, for food safety reasons and just because I want my orange, if it doesn’t come from my tree, at least to come from my country. I want to make sure that if the Chinese decide they don’t like us anymore that I can still have an orange with my breakfast. As Xenophon said, “Now imagine that Australia depended on China for 50 or 60 per cent of our food. Protecting Australia’s food security is as important as our national security.”
Damn straight, Senator.
So, as an experiment, I’m not buying anything from China for the month of May. In fact, I’m going to do my damndest not to buy anything that wasn’t grown or made in Australia for the month of May. And a week in, let me tell you, that isn’t easy. If I keep up this experiment, I won’t be buying any consumer electric goods. And Boy Z and Not Max will have to make due with the toys they’ve got***. And my wardrobe will remain much the same that it was in April. Because we don’t make clothes, toys or iPods in Australia. Even food shopping this week was a challenge. It took me twice as long and cost me about 10% more. But I did manage not to buy any Chinese food and the only foreign grown food that I bought were frozen mixed berries. I got a bit of a bollocking for buying the crappy Australian feta rather than the imported Greek, but it’s the principle of the thing and if I have to struggle through bland feta to insure my country’s food security, then buy god I’m willing to make that sacrifice. And apparently Dr. O’C will have to as well.
And I discovered that Xenophon was right. Food labeling is deceptive. Food manufacturers love to slap the “Made in Australia” logo on their product and then, in the fine print:
“Packaged in Australia with local and imported ingredients.”
Classy.
I’m not stupid. I know that global free trade is a reality and it’s not going anywhere. I don’t even know that it should. But when it comes to food, I think my adopted country should be self-supporting and I’m going to do my small part to see that it is.
———————————–
*And the not so bright.
** If my American readers care to argue with me then 1) go to the Rust Belt and have a look around and 2) do a bit of research about how you owe that several trillion dollars to.
***Actually, Boy Z triggered this whole exercise. His new favourite line of conversation involves ‘where’ things come from. I’m pretty sure he wants to be reminded who gave him a certain toy or when we got his latest football. But I’m a pedant or, depending on who you ask, a bit of a dick. So I answer the question literally and I started to become distressed about how many times the answer was ‘China’.
———————————–
Image credits:
If you like “Chinese Translation” the rest of M Ward’s “Post War” won’t be a disappointment. Buy it from
.
Popularity: 14% [?]

Stumble Upon
Del.icio.us
Buzz














by Jacob
06 May 2010 at 23:11
I can give one reason Australia may need to not get too hung up on not importing food: It’s a horrible place for agriculture in general. Isn’t it the driest continent after Antartica? Large swaths of the country are already having serious water issues and most food crops aren’t exactly dessert plants. The Middle East is one of the birthplaces of agriculture, but part of the reason it’s not a breadbasket anymore is that irrigation turned much of the ground too saline a very long time ago.
I agree with the rest of your points, though.
Jacob´s last blog ..My Son Will Pay for the Evils of My Youth
by Technobabe
07 May 2010 at 00:07
You brought up a point about the quality and safety of products made in China. A good point. I wonder what would happen if all people in America were to buy products made or produced only in America. Would the jobs be back in America?
Technobabe´s last blog ..Bring It To Me
by SciFi Dad
07 May 2010 at 00:33
One day, before I die, I want to run through the iPhone groves in Beijing.
Living in Canada, we have a similar situation (most food needs can be met by “buying Canadian”, but many goods are imported). I share your concerns.
SciFi Dad´s last blog ..Gender And The Workplace
Pingback
by And if life is really as short as they say, then why is the night … | Shanghai EXPO 2010
07 May 2010 at 01:12
[...] View original post here: And if life is really as short as they say, then why is the night … [...]
by muskrat
07 May 2010 at 02:51
As you know, this concerns me, too. Here, we eat a shitload of processed food full of corn syrup that our government encourages via subsidies and the creation of too much supply for the demand, so cheap shitty food for the farmer to “create” is cheap shitty food for the lazy or poor or uninformed (or all 3) to eat. I hate it. Hence this post: http://bit.ly/9Q81ml
I have thought about trying to do what you’re doing in May and blogging about it. I believe others have already. We recently found an organic farm and joined a coop to share grass finished meats and organic veggies/fruits from it. It starts in a few weeks. Can’t wait to be healthier and support locals here in GA.
muskrat´s last blog ..coming to a muskrat windshield near you: “‘tard on board!”
by muskrat
07 May 2010 at 02:56
btw, a billion people live in poverty in china. i hesitate to think of it is a nice place. there’s infanticide. horrible pollution. rampant corruption. little to no workplace safety oversight or measure. etc. etc. etc. and that’s on top of the obvious concerns with the plastics and food they churn out all over the world that are full of unsafe chemicals. i don’t think their emergence as the top dog in the world is a good thing, but our indebtedness to them makes it inevitable.
muskrat´s last blog ..coming to a muskrat windshield near you: “‘tard on board!”
by rassles
07 May 2010 at 03:43
So what you’re proposing is a movement, let’s say, a movement where everyone sings in four-part harmony, “You can get anything you want at Alice’s restaurant.” And if everyone sings that, if fifty people a day sing that – and we will achieve national sustainability and freedom from under the thumb of China. I’m in.
rassles´s last blog ..Standing Was Exhausting
by barbara
07 May 2010 at 06:09
I also look for australian products, not only to help this country but i have a worry about how hygenic the food from overseas is, has the factory passed its health inspection, and do they even have health inspections! Too many things from china lately have been very dodgy eg toys etc.
by mickey
07 May 2010 at 07:54
I’m with you, as always. We harp non-stop about the state of the economy and how nothing is made in America anymore, and then we insist on saving a buck or two by buying the shoes that are made in China. America was once the manufacturing behemoth, until we exported that honor across the Pacific. Our security and stability went with it.
Good luck with your mission.
mickey´s last blog ..Stand Up and Be Counted
by Dr O'C
07 May 2010 at 08:54
Is that why you bought your posh foreign coffee in late April?
by admin
07 May 2010 at 11:22
Jacob – Those things are true. And Australia has done a lot of damage to its environment with dodging agricultural and mining practices. That being said, we also have a very small population and are fully capable of feeding ourselves. And still exporting food.
Technobabe – No, the jobs don’t come back. But maybe you don’t lose anymore?
SciFi – There’s the same problem everywhere. Nobody in the ‘industrialised West’ makes anything anymore. In fact, Australia’s three biggest exports are:
1. Coal (to China)
2. Iron ore (to China)
3. Education services (to much of Asia)
So in other words, we’ve got some mining reserves – which will eventually be depleted – to help China power their iPhone plants and make our iPhones. The only other thing that we make is a decent tertiary education. I guess I’m in the right line of work anyway.
Muskrat – Fuckin’ hippy.
Seriously, I’m glad you’ve seen the light on food as well. The more people that demand decent, locally sourced food the better food we’re all going to get. I saw a statistic that 62% of children in Mississippi were obese (not overweight, OBESE) and 18% of those were medically obese, which means sick. How do you reckon they got that way. High fructose corn syrup, baby. At least it doesn’t come from China.
And I was being flip about China. I know there’s all sorts of problems and they’re certainly not a model for the world. But, you know what? It’s done. The U.S. and U.K. and the rest of the West is done – say hello to China and India.
Rassles- The baby jesus bless you for picking out that Arlo Guthrie reference! I knew I liked you for a reason. I was thinking of adding a tagline to my blog that said “Sitting on the Group W bench since 2007.” But then I thought that might be gay.
Barbara – Yeah, food safety is my thing as well. There were some problems with Chinese products in the U.S. not so long ago.
Mickey – Thanks. I don’t know how long it’s going to go for. I’ll need coffee before long.
Dr. O’C – Yep. Coffee is a real issue, actually. I don’t think we grow any coffee here. I’m going to check right now…
Sha ha! We do: http://www.mountaintopcoffee.com.au/
Phew.
by ellie
07 May 2010 at 23:38
I like the idea of the experiment.
Interested in hearing how it comes out.
I generally watch out for cholesterol levels in food rather than origin. Too much in this world competes for my limited bandwidth.
ellie´s last blog ..Internet People Rock
by April
08 May 2010 at 02:46
Before J was born I decided I was going to do everything I could to avoid buying her toys made in China because of numerous issues with recalls of toys with dangerous levels of lead. This means she doesn’t have as many toys, because the safe ones are more expensive, but how many toys does a child honestly need?
We’ve also recently moved to cut HFCS out of our diet, there is credible evidence (at least in my opinion) that it is metabolized in different ways than other sugars that might be contributing to obesity (lack of satiety for example). I can’t find the article now, but when J was still itty bitty I read a study that showed under the age of 7 kids have less of the enzyme that breaks down pesticides, so we also buy as much organic for her as we can. This works out well actually, because it’s mostly the unhealthy stuff that you can’t buy organic. I’m no hippy, and I’m also cheap, but her health is my number one concern!
April´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday: Sunglasses
by Not Afraid To Use It
08 May 2010 at 03:06
First, LOL @SciFi dad. That grove would be a dream come true.
I applaud you for your efforts at buying local. It IS tough, and when a family is on a tight budget even more so. I am really looking forward to a follow up to this to see how you did.
Not Afraid To Use It´s last blog ..Ace of Clubs
by barbara
08 May 2010 at 07:24
We do grow our own coffee, my husband and i just came back from Cairns and on the Atherton tablelands there are coffee plantations growing, and the coffee is delicious. You can take tours of the plantations or just city in the beautiful cafe and look out over the fields sipping on you fresh coffee.
by Allie
09 May 2010 at 07:23
Great post! I think it’s a fantastic experiment.
Allie´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday – My Book Jacket!!!
by suzer
11 May 2010 at 10:53
The worst newspaper in the world – wouldn’t all of Australia’s newspapers fall into that category, all being owned/produced/censored by the same bloke?
suzer´s last blog ..Whoosh Whoosh .. Bang
by Noah G
11 May 2010 at 11:12
Great stuff, someone should pay you to write. As a random and not regular reader of your blog I have a few items of comment:
1) Xenophon is amazingly close to xenophobe. I’m not judging, but it’s fitting.
2) worlds worst newspaper? You obviously haven’t read the Norwich (CT, USA) Bulletin, or the Jasper (TX, USA) Newsboy.
3) “if I have to struggle through bland feta to insure my country’s food security, then buy god I’m willing to make that sacrifice.” may be my favorite line of the year. If it was more musical I’d write a song about it.
4) hasn’t the farmer’s market craze hit Oz yet? Though I’ve noticed that ours in Indiana sells green peppers in January, so maybe the farmers aren’t as local as I thought.
Glad to see yer boys are doing well, Hi to Dr O’C.
Noah
by Penny
12 May 2010 at 00:46
This mother chose to live this experiment also…I haven’t read it yet, but find her goal along with your own inspiring. I have only minimally attempted to buy local and it is unfortunately more of a challenge than it should be, I’m going to have to put forth more effort and sacrifice.
http://www.amazon.com/Year-Without-Made-China-Adventure/dp/0470116137